Skip to main content

Preventing Tenant Issues Before They Start: How to Screen and Select Reliable Renters

Preventing Tenant Issues Before They Start: How to Screen and Select Reliable Renters

Why Tenant Screening Matters

One of the most effective ways to prevent tenant-related problems is to carefully screen applicants before signing a lease. According to a survey by the National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM), 81% of landlords who conducted thorough screenings reported fewer late payments and lease violations. A well-vetted tenant can ensure timely rent payments, proper property care, and a smooth rental experience.


1. Establish Clear Rental Criteria

Before advertising a rental property, create a set of clear, non-discriminatory screening criteria to ensure fairness and legal compliance.

  • Minimum credit score requirement
  • Stable employment and verifiable income (typically 3x the rent amount)
  • Positive rental history with no evictions
  • No serious criminal background

2. Require a Comprehensive Rental Application

A detailed rental application helps gather necessary information to evaluate potential tenants.

  • Full name and contact details
  • Employment history and proof of income
  • Previous landlord references
  • Consent for background and credit checks

3. Perform a Credit and Background Check

Credit and background checks provide insight into a tenant’s financial responsibility and rental behavior.

  • A credit report reveals outstanding debts, bankruptcies, or payment history.
  • A background check ensures the tenant does not have a history of property damage, fraud, or violent crimes.

4. Verify Employment and Income Stability

Reliable tenants should have a steady income that comfortably covers the rent.

  • Request recent pay stubs, tax returns, or an employer’s letter.
  • Confirm employment status and salary with the employer directly.
  • Look for long-term employment history to indicate stability.

5. Check Rental History and References

Previous landlords can provide valuable insight into an applicant’s behavior as a tenant.

  • Ask about payment punctuality and lease compliance.
  • Inquire if they took care of the rental property.
  • Be cautious of applicants who refuse to provide references.

6. Interview Potential Tenants

A brief interview helps assess the applicant’s personality and rental expectations.

  • Clarify lease terms, house rules, and pet policies.
  • Look for red flags, such as inconsistent answers or an unwillingness to provide information.
  • Gauge their attitude and willingness to cooperate.

7. Trust Your Instincts but Follow the Facts

While gut feelings can be helpful, always base decisions on factual data collected during the screening process. Stick to your pre-established criteria and avoid making exceptions that could lead to future issues.


Conclusion: A Strong Screening Process Ensures Long-Term Success

By following a thorough tenant screening process, landlords can significantly reduce rental disputes, late payments, and property damage. Prevention is always better than dealing with costly evictions and conflicts down the line.

Simplify Tenant Screening with Rent Easy Nola

At Rent Easy Nola, we take the guesswork out of tenant screening by handling background checks, income verification, and rental history assessments for you. Let us help you find responsible tenants who respect your property and pay rent on time.

📍 Address: 132 Terra Bella Blvd, Covington, LA 70433
 
📞 Phone: 985-710-3356
 
📧 Email: info@renteasynola.com

Partner with Rent Easy Nola today for hassle-free tenant management!


back